Rooted in Indiana. Rising Daily. 🌾 Proud Indiana Grown Bakery

51 W Main Street, New Palestine, IN 46163

Order Online for Pick-Up at the Bakery

1 1

Oatmeal Cream Pie

2 total reviews

Product format 4-Pack

$15.00 USD

Sale Sold out

Quantity

View full details

Let customers speak for us

from 94 reviews

Wonderful products and

Wonderful products and people!

Christy Leggins

09/11/2026

Excellent!

Anonymous

09/06/2026

My favorite bread

My favorite bread 🥰

Customer

08/27/2026

Just recently got to experience several products from this store

Just recently got to experience several products from this store. Even though the store has limited hours that doesn't meet my work schedule, they will still open the doors and let you purchase what you need. They are very personable! Love the product and hope they stay around for a long time.

Customer

08/26/2026

We have loved everything we have purchased at Sherrydough

We have loved everything we have purchased at Sherrydough.

Anonymous

08/24/2026

Awesome

Customer

08/22/2026

Great

Absolutely awesome!

Anonymous

08/21/2026

GuestBarn Treats

I purchase the sourdough rolls for the guests we host in our AirB&B. They are always a welcome treat that our guests love, as well as my husband and I. Delicious!

Jennifer Kay Hull

08/20/2026

Always tastes amazing and has great texture

Always tastes amazing and has great texture.

Anonymous

08/19/2026

Sherry is so knowledgeable and I really enjoyed

Sherry is so knowledgeable and I really enjoyed taking the class!! Thank you!! 🙏

Elishaba Hinchman

07/28/2026

the cinnamon roll was very good

the cinnamon roll was very good.
My son-in-law loved the jalapeno bread too.
My daughter liked the regular bread also.
I am interested in your gluten free items. When do you stock this group:?
Thank yo

Teresa L Coe

07/27/2026

Wonderful bread

Wonderful bread,delicious flavor,slices easily. I'm so pleased I found your shop. Freezes beautifully!! So very happy!!!

Deborah K Landers

07/27/2026

Enjoyable

Enjoyable class!

Ellen Smith

07/26/2026

Loved

Loved it!

Anonymous

07/22/2026

This bakery is wonderful.

This bakery is wonderful!

Marilyn D Nunamaker

07/20/2026